1
General Questions and Answers / Re: Phonon Dispersion Spectrum of GNR (Geometry optimization and mode separation)
« on: April 24, 2019, 16:34 »I am trying to calculate the phonon spectrum of a 8-dimer armchair graphene nanoribbon by following the example given by: https://docs.quantumwise.com/tutorials/phonon_calcs/phonon_calcs.html.
1. I want to optimize the geometry of the GNR and followed the exact procedure in the tutorial, but ended up with the error messages says: "The underlying configuration must be equal for the input DynamicMatrix and the object being calculated.".
Please attach the script (and log) file that produced that error.
Log file:
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| |
| QuantumATK 2018.06-SP1-1[Build 3f8f0aa] |
| |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| Bulk Bravais lattice |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
Type:
UnitCell
Lattice constants:
Primitive vectors:
u_1 = 20.000000 0.000000 0.000000 Ang
u_2 = 0.000000 30.000000 0.000000 Ang
u_3 = 0.000000 0.000000 4.262580 Ang
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| Bulk: Cartesian (Angstrom) / fractional |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
16
Bulk
C 1.000000e+01 1.069325e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.35644 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.192375e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.39746 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.069325e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.35644 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.315425e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.43847 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.438475e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.47949 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.192375e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.39746 0.16667
C 1.000000e+01 1.315425e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.43847 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.561525e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.52051 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.684575e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.56153 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.438475e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.47949 0.16667
C 1.000000e+01 1.561525e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.52051 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.807625e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.60254 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.930675e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.64356 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.684575e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.56153 0.16667
C 1.000000e+01 1.807625e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.60254 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.930675e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.64356 0.16667
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| Bulk Bravais lattice |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
Type:
UnitCell
Lattice constants:
Primitive vectors:
u_1 = 20.000000 0.000000 0.000000 Ang
u_2 = 0.000000 30.000000 0.000000 Ang
u_3 = 0.000000 0.000000 4.262580 Ang
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| Bulk: Cartesian (Angstrom) / fractional |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
16
Bulk
C 1.000000e+01 1.069325e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.35644 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.192375e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.39746 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.069325e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.35644 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.315425e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.43847 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.438475e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.47949 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.192375e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.39746 0.16667
C 1.000000e+01 1.315425e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.43847 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.561525e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.52051 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.684575e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.56153 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.438475e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.47949 0.16667
C 1.000000e+01 1.561525e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.52051 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.807625e+01 2.841720e+00 0.50000 0.60254 0.66667
C 1.000000e+01 1.930675e+01 3.552150e+00 0.50000 0.64356 0.83333
C 1.000000e+01 1.684575e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.56153 0.16667
C 1.000000e+01 1.807625e+01 1.420860e+00 0.50000 0.60254 0.33333
C 1.000000e+01 1.930675e+01 7.104300e-01 0.50000 0.64356 0.16667
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Automatically detected repetitions = [1 1 5] |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Geometry optimization using the LBFGS optimizer |
| Bravais Lattice: Unit Cell |
| External pressure: 0.000 GPa |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Step Step Length Volume Max. Force Stress Error Enthalpy |
| (Ang) (Ang**3) (eV/Ang) (GPa) (eV) |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| OPT 0 0.0000e+00 2557.548 5.5243e+00 0.83145 -121.497730 |
| OPT 1 9.2472e-02 2558.753 5.3353e+00 2.68902 -122.713293 |
| OPT 2 2.8905e-02 2560.234 1.3066e+00 2.06302 -123.296440 |
| OPT 3 1.6400e-02 2561.853 8.5016e-01 2.16680 -123.399393 |
| OPT 4 4.3608e-02 2566.991 5.1449e-01 2.13606 -123.513356 |
| OPT 5 5.6166e-02 2573.608 6.4237e-01 2.11419 -123.590251 |
| OPT 6 1.5705e-01 2592.110 7.8095e-01 1.88566 -123.751844 |
| OPT 7 4.1238e-02 2596.969 1.8093e+00 1.36723 -123.837476 |
| OPT 8 2.0723e-02 2599.410 5.6559e-01 1.46715 -123.885159 |
| OPT 9 2.8268e-03 2599.742 3.1653e-01 1.46115 -123.899648 |
| OPT 10 3.2920e-02 2603.620 3.6119e-01 1.39116 -123.939097 |
| OPT 11 9.4446e-02 2614.747 8.3807e-01 1.18355 -124.012071 |
| OPT 12 6.3825e-03 2615.499 4.5679e-01 1.24264 -124.037156 |
| OPT 13 6.4570e-03 2616.260 2.0636e-01 1.19434 -124.046906 |
| OPT 14 2.8009e-02 2619.560 3.0971e-01 1.08235 -124.068346 |
| OPT 15 4.8660e-02 2625.293 5.1829e-01 0.95292 -124.096410 |
| OPT 16 1.5392e-01 2643.426 7.7098e-01 0.59868 -124.169607 |
| OPT 17 9.0755e-03 2644.037 9.1345e-01 0.75792 -124.197892 |
| OPT 18 3.5366e-03 2644.453 1.9246e-01 0.68689 -124.212586 |
| OPT 19 5.2099e-03 2645.067 1.1090e-01 0.65509 -124.216511 |
| OPT 20 9.1618e-03 2646.146 1.6924e-01 0.62024 -124.220626 |
| OPT 21 3.1811e-02 2649.894 3.1806e-01 0.53683 -124.231473 |
| OPT 22 7.5396e-02 2658.777 4.3653e-01 0.38509 -124.252428 |
| OPT 23 1.4255e-01 2675.572 7.4041e-01 0.05542 -124.276380 |
| OPT 24 1.3229e-01 2691.157 6.1915e-01 0.13664 -124.283709 |
| OPT 25 5.3963e-02 2684.800 1.5280e-01 0.02938 -124.296767 |
| OPT 26 8.1788e-03 2683.836 4.7432e-02 0.00456 -124.297950 |
| OPT 27 1.5293e-03 2684.016 8.5408e-03 0.00130 -124.298067 |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Geometry optimization converged in 27 steps. |
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| Bulk Bravais lattice |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
Type:
UnitCell
Lattice constants:
Primitive vectors:
u_1 = 20.000000 0.000000 0.000000 Ang
u_2 = 0.000000 30.000000 0.000000 Ang
u_3 = 0.000000 0.000000 4.473361 Ang
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| Bulk: Cartesian (Angstrom) / fractional |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
16
Bulk
C 1.000000e+01 1.085563e+01 2.880052e+00 0.50000 0.36185 0.64382
C 1.000000e+01 1.186827e+01 3.787804e+00 0.50000 0.39561 0.84675
C 1.000000e+01 1.085563e+01 1.593309e+00 0.50000 0.36185 0.35618
C 1.000000e+01 1.313061e+01 2.987488e+00 0.50000 0.43769 0.66784
C 1.000000e+01 1.438038e+01 3.735839e+00 0.50000 0.47935 0.83513
C 1.000000e+01 1.186827e+01 6.855571e-01 0.50000 0.39561 0.15325
C 1.000000e+01 1.313061e+01 1.485873e+00 0.50000 0.43769 0.33216
C 1.000000e+01 1.561962e+01 2.974202e+00 0.50000 0.52065 0.66487
C 1.000000e+01 1.686939e+01 3.722553e+00 0.50000 0.56231 0.83216
C 1.000000e+01 1.438038e+01 7.375217e-01 0.50000 0.47935 0.16487
C 1.000000e+01 1.561962e+01 1.499159e+00 0.50000 0.52065 0.33513
C 1.000000e+01 1.813173e+01 2.922237e+00 0.50000 0.60439 0.65325
C 1.000000e+01 1.914437e+01 3.829989e+00 0.50000 0.63815 0.85618
C 1.000000e+01 1.686939e+01 7.508077e-01 0.50000 0.56231 0.16784
C 1.000000e+01 1.813173e+01 1.551123e+00 0.50000 0.60439 0.34675
C 1.000000e+01 1.914437e+01 6.433717e-01 0.50000 0.63815 0.14382