Is the experimental conductance of graphene comparable with ATK results?

[jinylee]

Dear ATK team

I wonder if the conductance of graphene calculated in ATK results can be comparable with an experimental value.

I already know most of the measured conductance of graphene reflects incoherent scattering, thus it can not comparable with ATK results.

But, how about the case in the paper "Phase-coherent transport in graphene quantum billards" (Science, 2007, 317, 1530-1533). I think under this measurement condition, the comparison between experiment and calculation can make sense.

I wonder this comparision can be possible.

Attached is the paper titled "Phase-coherent transport in graphene quantum billards"

Thank you in advance.

[Jess Wellendorff]

That is a really interesting scientific question, but I am not quite sure what the answer is. It may even be that you would get different answers depending on who you ask

If the measurement is really done under conditions that can be accurately modeled by theory, I would expect ATK to be the weapon of choice.